Wednesday, December 17, 2014



Dylan Detry                                                                                 812
M.S.51                                                                                         12/10/14

                                   English Language Arts
 

I can’t believe he cursed! That last paragraph was so shocking! The book The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian was banned across the county in many middle schools. The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian was written by Sherman Alexie. It is about a 13 year old Native American growing up, trying to fit in, and the obstacles he faces. The text should not be removed from middle school libraries because teenagers can relate, learn from, and need to be exposed to the life lessons in this book.

Teenagers need to be exposed to this book because it contains racism, profanity, violence, and death. Most teenagers who read this book will most likely go through racism, profanity, violence, and death.  That’s what this book is about, life. Teenagers who read this book need to know how to cope with these things. “I can’t imagine anyone finding this book appropriate for a 13- or 14 year old,” said Jennifer Anderson. Quoted from the article “Some Parents Seek to Ban: The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian.” By Ruth Fuller written on June 22, 2009. This is nonsense because this book is about a 13 year old whom turns 14.  

 The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian shouldn’t be banned because the main character Arnold was bullied. He shows ways of how to cope with bullying. In the book Arnold was bullied by his people because he switched from his school on the reservation, to a “white school”.  He coped with it by ignoring the bullies and it helped him throughout most of the story. When this no longer worked, Arnold ended up confronting the bullies by talking to them. Teenagers can use this lesson about how to deal with bullies in their everyday lives in middle school.

Even though many people may say that the book The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian should be banned because of the racist jokes, cursing, shootings, and death. These topics may take place in the book, but in fact, this is what goes on in life. There are many cartons for an even younger audience that is filled with violence, racism, and death. Two examples would be Tom & Jerry and The Road Runner. The Road Runner is filled with violence. Tom & Jerry is filled with violence and has a racist depiction of a black maid. The Nightly News also has tons of violence and death. Should we ban the news?  

Overall, it becomes clear that the book The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian shouldn’t be banned because teenagers can relate, learn from, and need to be exposed to the things that go on in this book. “[John] Whitehurst said the book is filled with positive, life-affirming messages and has an especially strong anti-alcohol message.” Quoted from “Some Parents Seek to Ban: The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian.” By Ruth Fuller written on June 22, 2009. Yes, the main character has a very difficult life. He experiences many hardship on a day to day basis but so do millions of teenagers all over the world. This book shows that therefore all teenagers despite their problems shouldn’t give up either.